Saturday, 29 November 2008

Bombay under attack

It is all over now. From the time Indhu called me to inform me about the terrorist attack in Bombay on Thursday morning till now many things have happened - all captured live on TV; the brutal acts of the terrorists, the heroic acts of the NSG commandos and the not so heroic act of the police (don't blame them, they cannot face an AK-47 or AK-56 with a lathi!!). More than 200 are dead and more than 300 are wounded in this madness. Properties worth many crores have been damaged; safety and security in 5 star luxury hotels are now questioned. The NSG Commandos had taken three days to flush out and kill the terrorists, numbering about 15. All Commado actions had taken place in buildings, not in the open. I have a simple question. Could the commandos have used a chemical stunner (like for example chrloroform or a similar chemical, like the one that comes in the not so intelligent advertisement that uses laughing gas to make the thieves laugh and forget their mission) to make all the people in the building unconscious and to act quickly to identify and catch the terrorists among the occupants of the building ? This could have been done in a fraction of the time taken for the conventional firing and bombing operations. We could have got the terrorists live which would have helped to provide solid evidence on the mission. What is your opinion? Is such a chemical available ? Has anyone used such a technique earlier to rescue the innocent hostages ? Should we ask this question to specialists ? Think.

6 comments:

Jan said...

What about the hostages? You should watch Denzel Washington's Imside Man which deals with a perfect bank robbery.

Maya said...

innovative!!! but donno hw successful it wld ve been! :)

Dr. L. Ramakrishnan said...

Dear Indhu,

ALL will get unconscious, including the hostages. At least they will not be killed as it happened with the conventional commando action. Life will be normal to them after they regain consciousness. I have experience of this myself; I was given chloroform when my broken arm was set. I could see I was sinking...but when I regained my consciousness, I was OK to do things the normal way. Stunning is a well known technique; why not follow the same in this context ?

Love

Appa

Dr. L. Ramakrishnan said...

Dear Maya,

Quite a lot of preparation is needed to make this effective; my proposal is for future incidents of this nature. If the commandos had thought of this method much before the Bombay incident, they could have successfully used it. Of course a lot of research, preparation, drills, pilots etc., are required. An extra-ordinary situation requires an extra-ordinary solution.

Love

Appa

L.Ramanathan said...

Dear Brother,

Your suggestion is good. But at the time of emergency whether it will work or not is to be studied. In this instance people in the room have locked their room from inside. If you argue that the chloroform can be injected through central A/C system,that has a snag.The chemical used in the central A/C system and chloroform are not compatible with each .Your suggestion is to be tried with some other chemical.

Dr. L. Ramakrishnan said...

Dear Brother,

The CFC which is used for refrigeration is in a closed system. Air circulation duct has to be used for chemical diffusion; this duct is NOT connected to the cooling coils. Air is cooled when it passes through the cooling coils of the AC. Hence there is no chance of non-compatible chemicals coming together. Further, CFC and Chloroform are compatable, chemically.

Affectionately
Ramakrishnan

Powered By Blogger